Bonus question, what is the mechanism behind it?
If you’ve ever heard the term saline, it’s a sodium chloride water solution at 0.9% concentration. This is basically the threshold. Sea water is like 3.5%.
WHO recommendation is 5 grams of salt per day. Saline is thus 3 to 5 times too concentrated to be healthy.
Normal Saline (NS, the 0.9% stuff) is usually injected, not ingested.
That is a much more specific answer than what I was hoping for. Thanks!
Osmosis. Your body needs sodium to function properly. Your blood is salty. They use saline as an analog all the time.
Osmosis causes areas of high concentration to cross a barier to areas of low concentration. That barier being the cell
wallmembrane. Which means if you drink a bunch of salty water, when it’s going through your blood stream, water will leave the inside of your cells (high concentration) and go to the blood(low concentration water because of all the extra salt) therefore water is leaving your cells actively causing you to dehydrate.later your kidneys will get a big workout removing all that salt from your blood.
Only plants and certain bacteria have cell walls
Duh, yup, cell membrane.
How on Earth are you getting downvoted for this? You’re not 100% right, namely in that most prokaryotes have walls, as do plants, fungi, and eukaryotic algae, but the most salient point here is that humans do not, and the person you’re replying to was thinking of the cell membrane.
The difference between these two is taught in fifth-grade biology; this isn’t “um, ackshually” about jargon.
Because it’s not relevant to the explanation. And yes, it’s a fifth grade technicality. So it’s like bitching about a sentence starting with ‘And’, when you’re discussing Shakespearean poetry.
It’s more analogous to describing a work of Shakespeare by saying “In this Shakespeare play, Romeo is the prince of Denmark where his uncle Claudius has killed his father and plans to marry his mother.” It’s an accurate description with one name of something swapped for another related but distinct term. It’s fine for understanding, but then the next time you talk to others they’ll be confused on why you’re saying Romeo talks about Yorick. There’s nothing wrong with correcting terminology.
My issue is that they didn’t correct the terminology, they said it’s not a cell wall without providing the correct term that it’s a cell membrane.
Also- cell walls can withstand large osmotic pressures. In a cell without a wall this is a bigger issue and can kill the cell. In fact plants do a variety of movements by pumping water in and out of cells with strong walls. So it’s not just a different term. Wall paints the wrong picture.
By the time someone’s asking a basic, fifth-grade-level biology question like “why does ocean water dehydrate you?”, there’s nothing wrong with correcting basic, fifth-grade-level biology misinformation within the basic, fifth-grade-level biology explanation.
They weren’t rude about it; they were neutrally pointing out a mistake.
User name checks out.
It’s all about balancing sodium levels in your blood. If you’re sweating a lot, you are losing salts and if you’re just chugging plain water to replace the fluids in your body the balance could get off. That’s when drinking electrolytes are effective.
If you aren’t sweating a lot and you drink salty water, your kidneys are just going to filter out the excess salts and you’ll pee them out, regardless of if it’s ocean water or electrolyte drink mix.
If your salts are fine, but you’re stranded on a desert island with no fresh water, then you don’t want to be peeing out excess salts because you’ll already have to little fluid in your body.
Also, a lot of marketing for electrolytes these days encourage drinking them in day to day life.
This is largely bullshit marketing to get people to increase demand for their products. Most people get plenty of sodium from their daily diets and you only need electrolytes when sweating a lot, e.g. manual labor outside in extreme temps or intense sports/workouts.
Most people probably get way too much sodium honestly.
While I want to agree that most people don’t need these sports drinks, it seems like a few people I know benefit from it. Obviously, it could be placebo, but they’re also people that intermittent fast. It seems like it might help balance sodium levels through the day.
I’m sure we agree that not every fucking cookie, chip, ice cream, and coffee needs to be packed with protein, though. I’m well aware many meals had zero protein, but now every damn component of a meal and be proteined. That shit is insane and office works are gobbling it up.
The hydration is likely helping them far more than the electrolytes. But either way, seems like minimal or no harm except perhaps to the pocketbook, so sure.
Maximum should be 1% sodium chloride on a weight basis since that is (i believe) the concentration in our blood, while seawater would be (i belive) at 3.5% so many times more.
The mechanism is in your
bladderkidneys. You’re bladder can only process fluids up to 2% (maybe as low as 0.8%?) sodium concentration. Ocean water is about43.5%. So if you drink a cup of ocean water, it needs to leech about a cup of water from somewhere else in your body. Sodium and other electrolytes aren’t added to drinks to aid in hydration specifically. They’re actually to make sure your electrolytes don’t go out of balance. Usually the conversation about hydration comes up relative to being dehydrated for some reason. When you sweat, you lose more than just water. You lose electrolytes like sodium and magnesium salts. If you only replenish with just water, you could suffer from that electrolyte imbalance. So things like sports drinks add in those things in the amounts one typically loses while sweating.ETA some corrections.
While we’re on the subject of science, our body has this crazy way of telling us we’re dehydrated: it’s called thirst.
My understanding is that it is not the amount of sodium in the water, but the amount of sodium in your body. If you drink ocean water when you are well hydrated, then I don’t think you will have a problem, but if you drink it when you are dehydrated, you will have a problem
If it was not obvious, I am not a doctor or expert of any kind. Do not take my comment as facts.
Also not a doctor, still, I advise against taking this comment with a grain of salt when you are dehydrated.
I anal, and I recommend checking this comment with a lawyer before acting on it. Also, IANAL.
Just commenting that this is not exactly correct.
Just download the kidneys upgrade, you’ll be able to filter and reuse excess salt and turn it into burnable energy. Or you can roll to classify it as spice if you want to hit someone with a bit of sarcasm or sass.
Dialysis here. Where can I get this kidney upgrade? heh
It’s at your nearest ripperdoc. Check the map for Hexagon with the profile of a person in it.
(Sadly this was my lazy joke, because I went and grabbed the kidneyupgrade.ddns.net domain and wanted to make a fun website for it, but then I found out the kitchen sinks are leaking and well… You get the point)
I keep having an excess of square tuits and no rounds ones, I do indeed understand. And thank you for the chuckle :)
Also not an MD, but this sounds right. IV saline is isotonic. Seawater has over three times the concentration of sodium.





