Prime Minister Mark Carney condemned Russia’s war with Ukraine while Russian President Vladimir Putin, the man prosecuting that war, was in the room for leaders’ speeches at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in China.
Carney’s speech principally focused on the government’s efforts to boost the economy and make the country a more favourable place to invest for Asian partners.
However, toward the end of those remarks to the plenary session on Thursday, he veered into the yearslong conflict that has threatened Ukraine’s territorial integrity, killed tens of thousands of soldiers and civilians and shaken the global economy.
“Sustained prosperity also depends on a stable international environment. Geopolitical crises, including Russia’s illegal invasion of Ukraine, continue to have material economic consequences across the Asia-Pacific and beyond,” Carney said, according to a copy of his prepared remarks shared by the Prime Minister’s Office.
“illegal invasion” always seemed weird as a term to me, surely they’re all illegal?
Geopolitical language can seem super weird, but words (in official statements, from sane governments) are chosen very specifically because of the way they translate into other languages. There can be be no ambiguity. It might seem redundant and pedantic, but the word “invasion” in english, which has a decidedly negative connotation, might only be translatable to a neutral word in other languages. It might translate to the equivalent of “Incursion” or “Advance” or whatever. That’s why they qualify it with “Illegal” a word that translates with a negative connotation. Same reason they issue a statement “Condemning” or “Denouncing” another country. The words don’t really do anything of substance, but it communicates very unambiguously that " We saw what you did and we do not like it" which seems pointless, but a lot of politics is a very tedious, slow burn towards an outcome of either escalation or de-escalation. Ambiguity in language can allow deceit or misunderstanding which can in turn lead to escalation. See the build up to and substance of Neville Chamberlain’s “Peace in our time” speech. Spoilers, there wasn’t any.
The words also need to translate in equal meaning to all the major languages of the present parties, not just the target party, so as to clearly communicate to third-party countries something like “We saw what they did, and we didn’t like it, and we want you to know that we don’t like it when countries do that.”
Thing is, from Russia’s perspective it’s legal, because they make their law.
I believe him to have been speaking in the context of international law. A nation’s domestic laws are not applicable or relevant beyond their borders.
Yeah, I mean there’s that thing that the Holocaust was legal, the Slave Trade was legal, legal doesn’t mean shit on this scale.
On the flip side, the Allies invaded Germany, which I’m pretty sure was against German law.
Will carnival man do the same thing about the Iran “thing”?
ITT: a great source to grow your blocklists.
Don’t accept any invitations to rooms with balconies.
Why would Canada’s guy have anything to fear from that little shit Putin? Canada can afford enough security to protect Carney from Russians. Russia can’t even defeat Ukraine after all this time at war, and they haven’t been able to touch Zelensky after trying many times.
Carney could hire ex-PM Jean Chrétien to defend him. Soapstone is easy to come by.
Give him a Shawinigan Handshake
They could also hire those badass Canadian forces guys. What are they called again? Justin Trudeau Force 2 or something…
I’m always confused when some complete asshole does something I totally agree with.
why do you hate him? I don’t really follow Canadian politics
Pretty much what Yamees said below. I think a lot of people like him because he isn’t taking shit from TACO, which is great but he’s still right wing. Same thing goes for Zelenski. My heart goes out to the people of Ukraine and I think to some extent he has done a good job in the war, but he was pretty crooked before it began and used the war to cancel elections. There was also some kind of anti-corruption law he helped crush or something. When it comes right down to it they are all politicians. The only politician I ever voted FOR was Bernie Sanders. Usually I vote against them. Tomorrow, I’ll probably find out that he’s horrible too somehow.
He’s still banker who is selling off public assets and leaning into establishing a surveillance state like any other conservative on the planet right now. He just also happens to not be frothing at the mouth like Pierre(capital C conservative leader), so we’re stuck with him getting his way uncontested by both the right and our left leaning party because fear of America going full Nazi pushed all those votes to him.
sit down PP. stop smelling like poopoo.
Did he mention illegal US bombing of Iran?
just cuz something is mentioned in context doesnt exclude everything else by default.
theres so much to mention in so little time haha.
On one hand I applaud Carney, but to also not say the same about America’s Iran war is disappointing to say the least. Guess we know where Carney and Canadians stand.
if not troll, why troll shaped?
Totally agree. But why would he say anything about the US’s invasion of Iran when he came out the very next day supporting it?
Before defending Ukraine, how about condemning buddy’s Trump “legal” try of annexation of Canada?
How’s stable environment between Ca/USA?
“Boost economy”, what that even means in today’s economy?
“more favourable place to invest” while making it really hard for China to invest?
What happened to Russia’s investments?
The man was in the room, at least the was there and not a lost puppy barking at the wrong tree
lol, you need some more practice still.
fuck off russian bot
Sure, troll or bot if I have a different opinion. They are making Carney some hereo but nobody sees an elephant in the room
I mean, if he’s gonna condemn anything in particular, why not the US war in Iran? It’s by far the closest parallel the US has done to the Russian invasion of Ukraine, and wouldn’t be out of place at all to include next to his condemnation of the Russian invasion.
And tbh, the US-Israeli campaign against Iran has been more geopolitically destabilizing than the Russian invasion of Ukraine, considering how vital the Strait of Hormuz and Bab al-Mandab are.




