cross-posted from: https://lemmy.world/post/51388116
With the end of physical PlayStation games looming, the need for clear digital ownership rights is more pressing than ever.
For its part, Sony believes your rights are very clear: you do not own your digital games, and it’s unlikely you’re stupid enough to believe otherwise. At least, that’s roughly the argument the company’s lawyers are presenting in response to a proposed class-action lawsuit.
Sony argues that its current customer-facing disclosures ensure that “reasonable consumers would not be misled” into believing they actually own their digital games. That’s according to a Game File report (paid article link) citing an August 21 filing Sony’s lawyers made in California’s Northern District.
So by that logic, Sony also don’t own the games and therefore have nothing to sell.
If this logic were true, then pirating a game couldn’t be theft because the original owner still has possession of it.
I hope that backfires in their face.
Modern Piracy is never theft.
Piracy has never been tried successfully as theft, because it does not deprive the original owner of their lawful copy. It has always been tried as Copyright Infringement.
I don’t believe anyone owns media. I believe “buying media” should provide, baring illegal action on the buyers part, an irrevocable license to the media. Additionally, if the media is only available online, the media needs to be provided for the expected lifetime of the buyer.
Why do they use terms like “Buy”, and “Purchase”, then?
I mean, I bought the only peanut butter ever made. There was only one, I bought it.
There’s a reason everyone says they’re going to purchase a copy of a game. No one ever thinks they are buying the master and suddenly owns the IP. Everyone at Sony has rocks for brains.
Sleazy lawyers expect the judge to have rocks for brains and buy this argument. They’re relying on the ignorance of digital goods and how they work. I hope they didn’t forget that neat word from the last corpo scam before AI, non-fungible. Every copy is indistinguishable from all the other copies. If you can sell infinite copies at no cost, then people should be able to buy a copy and keep it in a working state forever. Fuck DRM.
I really, really hope this backfires. They are arguing in public about how we should not have rights to the games they offer us and somehow don’t care how bad the optics look? I swear I think I am done with Sony and I have been with them since the 90s. They need consequences for trying to treat its consumers with such disregard. At least most companies try to hide it behind closed doors.
Sonys been evil as fuck for decades dude, remember when 20 years ago they hid rootkits in their cds for drm protection.
That whole thing was absolutely fucking nuts.
Have you seen the source? They were fucking script kiddies.
They only looked good a few years ago because Microsoft was racing them to the bottom with the early Xbox One drama.
Absolutely, I guess I was more forgiving back then. Plus this feels way more agressive and covers everybody. I think it’s more the fact that it’s in the public eye and they don’t care at all which is making it worse to me.
Oh my god, Sony. Fuck off.
What a strawman argument. No one has ever tried to argue that.
That lawyer is an idiot. He’s arguing that Sony willfully double dipped n times after the first sale of each and every digital title.
If I were a judge, and someone presented a case so fucking stupid, I would dismiss the case with prejudice.
Lawyers have to at least pretend to do their jobs.
Sony used to sell physical LP’s and CD’s.
“we only manufactured one! When you bought it, we no longer owned it!”
